: Midterm Exam: Introduction to Psychology

by Danny Oppenheimer

Audio version created with Paper2Audio.

Listen on Paper2Audio

Danny Oppenheimer

Audio by Paper2Audio.

Q.1:

Q.2:

Q.3:

Q.4:

Q.5:

Q.6:

Q.7:

Q.8:

Total

Please answer 7 of the 8 questions. If you answer all 8, we simply won't grade question 8. Be concise – 100 words (the length of these instructions) should be more than enough space to answer the questions (feel free to use bullet points). However, it is important to fully articulate your logic – we will not assume information that you do not include in your answer. In addition to getting points for correct answers, deductions will be given for saying things that are incorrect, or for including substantial content irrelevant to the question.

1) A researcher hypothesizes that people are more honest in the dark. Identify the variables that will need to be operationalized to test this hypothesis, and propose a high quality operational definition for each such variable.

There are an infinite number of good answers here. The trick is that a good answer will be both valid and precise. Precise is that if this definition was given to 10 research teams, they would all implement in the same way. Valid is that it actually measures the constructs of interest, and doesn't also measure constructs not of interest.

Two things that need to be operationalized:

1. Honesty – Ask people a series of 10 questions that are embarrassing and they might be tempted to lie (malingering scale), such as “Have you ever picked your nose”, “do you brush your teeth twice a day every day” etcetera Honesty is operationalized as a larger number of yes answers, on the assumption that on average most people have done most of the activities. Alternate: Give people a trivia test with 10 questions and let them score their own test (provide them with an answer key), give a bonus payment or candy for every correct answer. Secretly record the original answers and score independently – honesty is operationalized as the size of the discrepancy smaller discrepancy = more honesty.

2. Darkness — Have a room lit with a 20 lumen light versus an 80 lumen light.

Alternative: Have participants wearing dark glasses versus clear lenses. I don't know how dark glasses are scored on how dark they are, but to operationalize this I'd choose the most popular dark glasses sold on Amazon, which would block more light than lenses with no tinting at all.

2) During a stage show, a hypnotist puts several audience members into a trance, and gives a post-hypnotic suggestion that the word “fork” will be the funniest thing in the world. Upon waking, the hypnotist mentions a fork, and the audience members burst into laughter. A skeptic claims that the audience members are just “playing along” for the show, and don't genuinely think the word is funny. Using what we know about bio psychology, how could we test whether the skeptic's claim is correct? (hint: be sure to explain the logic behind why this test would be informative).

We could record the laughter and slow it down so that it matches the pitch that other primate vocal chords can produce. Other primates have spontaneously laughter but not volitional laughter, so if the slowed recording sounds like what primate laughter sounds like, we'll know it's not volitional.

3) A researcher thinks that the process of determining whether an object is best described as a basic level category or a subordinate level category is lateralized to the left hemisphere of the brain. To test this, the researcher will use the lateralizer software and experimental design/paradigm. 1) Come up with a set of example stimuli that can effectively test this hypothesis (4 basic level and 4 subordinate level – be sure to clearly indicate which are which). Draw (and label) a graph of what the results should look like if this hypothesis is correct.

There are an infinite number of possible correct answers here. For example: Basic Level: Dog, Cat, Car, Chair

Subordinate level: Poodle, Calico, Sedan, Recliner. The key is that basic level is the level at which people spontaneously describe a picture of an object, and subordinate is more precise than that, describing a subcategory of a basic level

Can't draw a graph on the digital key, but will be hand drawn on the actual key.

4) Explain the similarities between retinotopic organization in vision and the sensory homunculus in proprioception. Why does it make sense for the brain's perceptual systems to be organized this way?

The visual system is organized such that neurons responsible for a particular area of the visual field are physically located as neighbors to neurons that are responsible for neighboring areas of the visual field. That is, the neurons in the visual cortex form a map that directly corresponds to the physical spaces that they are responsible for.

The Homunculus is organized such that neurons responsible for perceiving touch at a certain part of the body are physically located as neighbors to neurons responsible for neighboring part of the body. Same as the visual system, but for touch.

This organization allows for lateral inhibition to be effective. This allows for edge detection in the visual system and precise location of touch in the sensory system – neighboring neurons inhibit each other, so when one part of the visual field has stimulation, but the neighboring space does not, the neuron that activates with the first part can suppress the neurons responsible for the part where there is no stimulation (similar for the homunculus). This increases the precision of sensation.

5) Nico is an environmentalist who proudly walks to work every morning to reduce her carbon footprint and convinces her employer to create a rewards program to encourage her co-workers to also walk to work: anybody (including Nico!) who walks to work at least 4 days a week gets a free dessert in the company cafeteria. After three months, the company discontinues the reward program as a cost cutting measure. Based on what we know about overjustification effects, what specific behavioral changes would we expect to observe in Nico as the program is discontinued, and why?

Overjustification is that if you are compensated for something that you had intrinsic motivation to do (would have done anyway) it ruins the intrinsic motivation and kills desire to engage in that behavior. Nico intrinsically wanted to walk to work, once she was paid, that killed intrinsic motivation. When the payment ceases, Nico is less likely to walk to work than before she was paid in the first place..

6) Most people have no explicit memories from the first year of their lives – a phenomenon known as infantile amnesia. Nonetheless, children who experience repeated trauma in infancy can be conditioned to fear stimuli related to those trauma, and those fear responses can persist through adulthood. What does this pair of results suggest about the timing of brain regions involved in memory storage and retrieval through infancy?

Explicit memories are formed in the hippocampus, fear conditioning happens in the amygdala. This pattern of results suggests that the hippocampus develops later than the amygdala. Amygdala develops early, allowing fear conditioning for infant trauma, hippocampus is not available until later ,when people have explicit memories.

If a student mentions the pre-frontal cortex cortex not being developed because it can't inhibit fear learning, that maybe merits a half a point if it's well defended, but that's about exhibiting fear responses, not learning them, so they can't get full credit.

7) Maria is a dancer who grew up learning traditional folk dances in her rural village. After moving to the big city to pursue her career, she tries to incorporate the dances from her childhood into her modern routines, and finds that she can't recall specific dance steps when practicing in her modern, urban dance studio. However, when she returns to her rural home for the holidays, she finds that the dance steps come to her naturally. How would psychologists most likely explain this pattern of experiences?

This is state dependent memory. The cues of her home village help her retrieve the dance steps. In the city, those cues are unavailable and she can't remember it. When she goes home, the cues are back and she remember the dance again.

8) On the game show "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?," contestants can use the "Ask the Audience" lifeline when unsure of an answer. Everybody in the audience votes on the correct answer, and the contestant sees what the audience thinks is correct. The audience's response has been shown to be correct about 91% of the time, much higher than the sub-80% accuracy rates of contestants answering similar difficulty questions without asking the audience. Given that the actual contestants are drawn from the same pool of people as the members of the audience, why does the audience do so much better?

This is wisdom of crowds. If we assume that there is some signal and some noise in every answer, the audience noise will cancel, creating more signal/noise ratio and thus being more accurate than any individual would have been.